by Derek Smith
•
06 May, 2024
In my experience it doesn’t matter what the size of sensor a camera has, most lenses will have a corner-to-corner optimum sharpness in the range of f/4 – f/8 aperture, often called “the sweet spot”. Camera lens design will often give a sharp performance in the centre at the widest aperture, for example at f/1.4, with the lens aperture resolving to sharper corner to corner sharpness as it is stopped down, then the performance deteriorates again becoming softer as the lens is stopped down further owing to diffraction at apertures above f/16, personally I wouldn’t push a lens on an APS-C camera much past f/11. Why does this matter? For landscape photography ideally a photographer would want foreground to background sharpness, and simply always choosing to select an aperture of f/10, or f/16 arbitrarily may not give the correct front to back sharpness required. This foreground to background sharpness is defined in cameras as Depth of Field (DoF). Depth of Field is a factor of sensor size, closeness to the subject, and the focal length of the lens used, this attached image of a worm cast on a sandy beach illustrates perfectly the effect of DoF, shot at f/5.6 on an APS-C sensor, the band of sharpness runs through the focus point on the worm cast. For macro photography a photographer often needs to be close to the subject, which reduces the DoF, requiring a photographer to focus stack the images. Many photographers opt for a small crop sensor of micro four thirds format from Olympus, or Panasonic, to maximise the DoF in this genre of photography. Many of you know that I enjoy portrait, and fashion photography, DoF is critical as the focus should be on the eyes. A few years back, I succumbed to social media advice that I needed a full frame camera for portraiture, especially with an 85mm f/1.8 lens shooting wide open. Unfortunately, the DoF was razor thin, the lens a Sony FE 85mm f/1.8, and Sony A7 ii was heavy as a combination, and the large lens provided little room for my fingers on the handgrip, the Sony cameras were sold within a few months. On my last model photo shoot, with Ivy in Skegness, I used a new TT Artisans 56mm f/1.8 on my Fuji APS-C camera, shooting wide open the eyes were in focus but the ears, and nose were soft, stopping down to f/4 gave better focus on the face, but still retained a smooth out of focus background – bokeh. I use an app called PhotoPills on my mobile phone, the app provides a tremendous amount of data relevant to photography including a DoF lookup, here are the results from my past, and current cameras, and lenses. Camera Sensor Lens Aperture DoF Fuji 26Mp Sigma 30mm f/1.4 0.36m Fuji 26Mp Fuji 16-80mm f/4 @80mm 0.14m Fuji 26Mp TT Art 56mm f/1.4 0.13m Sony A7 ii 24Mp Sony FE 85mm f/1.8 0.08m Olympus EM5 20Mp Sigma 30mm f/1.4 0.28m Knowledge is power!! I know that any DoF greater than 0.20m for portraits will provide good definition on the face, without any softening of facial features. The Sigma 30mm f/1.4 lens allows for portraits to be shot wide open. My TT Artisans 56mm f/1.8 lens is probably best stopped down to f/4, also the benefit of stopping this lens down is that the lens will provide improved sharpness at this aperture. Mark Denny has posted a YouTube video on this topic which some of you may find useful. https://youtu.be/CdNzZ9oLdKc?si=kL0fgTH7A6GUnhIM In this video Mark discusses his mistakes in selecting aperture in landscape photography, he also touches on finding the “sweet spot” of a lens. My photo of Jayne, “English Rose”, was taken with the Sigma 30mm f/1.4, shot wide open at f/1.4, the foreground petals are out of focus but importantly the eyes, and facial features are in sharp detail. This portrait of Fleur, taken in natural light with the Olympus EM5, and the Sigma 30mm lens, was shot at f/2 again preserving fine detail. For landscape photography the image here is of the rocks in a bay at Flamborough, I can see on the set of images taken at this time that I’ve fallen into the trap outlined by Mark Denney of shooting at a fixed aperture, luckily in this case the selected aperture of f/8 worked on this image, with the Fuji 16-80mm zoom lens at 16mm, the foreground rocks are in sharp detail, and the background cliff still retains a lot of detail.